5+ Bedroom Homes in Montauk, NY

24 listings available — swipe to find your perfect match.

Start Swiping in Montauk

5+ Bedroom Homes in Montauk, NY

$5,995,000

17 Upland Rd

Montauk, NY

6 bd6 ba5,000 sqft

$14,950,000

22 Maple St

Montauk, NY

6 bd8 ba9,488 sqft

$3,995,000

21 Dubois Pl

Montauk, NY

6 bd6 ba4,453 sqft

$8,995,000

148 Tuthill Rd

Montauk, NY

10 bd9 ba5,780 sqft

$9,495,000

16 and 18 Wills Point Rd

Montauk, NY

5 bd9 ba

$4,995,000

19 Elm Ln

Montauk, NY

6 bd5 ba5,150 sqft

$3,650,000

1 Florida Rd

Montauk, NY

5 bd6 ba3,378 sqft

$5,490,000

112 Soundview Dr

Montauk, NY

5 bd4 ba2,100 sqft

$3,995,000

94 Laurel Dr

Montauk, NY

5 bd6 ba4,100 sqft

$1,900,000

70 Fairview Ave

Montauk, NY

5 bd3 ba3,766 sqft

$5,450,000

23 Sycamore Ln

Montauk, NY

5 bd6 ba4,450 sqft

$9,750,000

10 Maple St

Montauk, NY

7 bd7 ba8,500 sqft

$2,895,000

161 Monroe Dr

Montauk, NY

5 bd4 ba2,380 sqft

$2,999,000

18 Shore Rd

Montauk, NY

9 bd7 ba3,572 sqft

$5,995,000

29 Monroe Dr

Montauk, NY

6 bd7 ba5,000 sqft

$2,999,000

18 N Shore Rd

Montauk, NY

6 bd4 ba

$2,400,000

3 Farrington Rd

Montauk, NY

5 bd5 ba4,200 sqft

$17,495,000

40 Deforest Rd

Montauk, NY

6 bd6 ba4,800 sqft

$12,850,000

283 Old Montauk Hwy

Montauk, NY

6 bd10 ba8,000 sqft

$6,295,000

113 S Edgemere St

Montauk, NY

7 bd9 ba7,141 sqft

$14,500,000

70 Kettle Hole Rd

Montauk, NY

6 bd7 ba6,000 sqft

$9,590,000

131 137 South Edgemere St

Montauk, NY

14 bd14 ba6,000 sqft

$5,795,000

137 S Edgemere St

Montauk, NY

7 bd8 ba4,721 sqft

$3,795,000

131 S Edgemere St

Montauk, NY

5 bd8 ba3,200 sqft

Montauk, NY has 24 homes with 5 or more bedrooms currently for sale. Five-bedroom homes are ideal for large families, multi-generational households, or buyers who want dedicated spaces for offices, gyms, or entertainment. Browse every 5+ bedroom listing in Montauk on HomeSwipr.

Also in Long Island

Great Neck Garden City East Hampton Southampton