33 Agnew Ave, Montauk, NY
3 bd · 2 ba · 0 sqft Single Family listed at $2,600,000, built in 1984 in the The Hamptons neighborhood.
About this home
Located in coveted Ditch Plains, this 3-bedroom + loft, 2-bathroom beach house offers the perfect blend of comfort and coastal charm. The open-concept living, dining, and kitchen area flows seamlessly to a front deck through sliding glass doors, creating an easy indoor-outdoor lifestyle ideal for summer living. Upstairs, a private balcony off the second-story bedroom provides a quiet place to unwind, while the spacious rear deck is perfect for entertaining. Additional features include an outdoor shower and ample outdoor space to enjoy the laid-back beach lifestyle. Just moments from the ocean and some of the most sought-after beaches and surf breaks, this is a true Ditch Plains retreat.
What it's like to live here
AIListed by
Property details
- Price
- $2,600,000
- Bedrooms
- 3
- Bathrooms
- 2
- Year built
- 1984
- Lot size
- 7,405 sqft
- Type
- Single Family
- Days on market
- 20
- Est. property tax
- $35,880/yr · $2,990/mo · 1.38% NY avg
- Last sold
- $875,000 · Dec 2008
Estimated monthly payment
Can I afford this?
See what fits your income
Price history
▼ 7.9%Most recent change on 2026-05-06: $2,600,000 → $2,395,000.
- May 6, 2026$2,395,000Price change
- Mar 25, 2026$2,600,000Initial list price
- Dec 29, 2008$875,000Sold
- Dec 5, 2001$430,000Sold
Location
This home is located in Montauk, NY, in the Long Island area. Browse more Montauk listings on the Montauk market page or explore the full Montauk market report.
About Montauk: Montauk is a hamlet and census-designated place (CDP) in East Hampton and Suffolk County, New York, on the eastern end of the South Shore of Long Island in the United States. As of the 2020 United States census, the CDP's population was 4,318. (source: Wikipedia)
Climate: Average year-round temperature is 53°F with 224 dry days per year and 43.2 inches of annual rainfall.
Home Intelligence
Neighborhood (zip 11954)
This neighborhood is predominantly owner-occupied (84%). Median age is 49.4; 31% hold a bachelor's degree; median household income is $138,900.
- Median income
- $138,900
- Median age
- 49.4
- Owner-occupied
- 84.1%
- Bachelor's degree
- 31.0%
- Census median home value
- $1,071,700
Source: US Census Bureau American Community Survey 5-year estimates.
Browse 0+ nearby homes on the map
See 0 more Montauk homes on the map
Open map →