Homes Under $500K in Montauk, NY
14 listings available — swipe to find your perfect match.
Start Swiping in MontaukHomes Under $500K in Montauk, NY
$490,000236 Edgemere St
Montauk, NY
$399,000131 S Emerson Ave Unit 216
Montauk, NY
$499,000131 S Emerson Ave Unit 224
Montauk, NY
$475,000727 Old Montauk Hwy Unit 224
Montauk, NY
$490,000236 Edgemere St Apt 127
Montauk, NY
$454,000236 Edgemere St Unit 131
Montauk, NY
$495,0006 Soundview Dr Unit G
Montauk, NY
$499,999131 S Emerson Ave Unit 235
Montauk, NY
$399,000236 Edgemere St Apt 423
Montauk, NY
$499,000118 S Emerson Ave Unit 19
Montauk, NY
$390,000236 Edgemere St Apt 115
Montauk, NY
$385,000236 Edgemere St Apt 219
Montauk, NY
$440,000236 Edgemere St Unit 101
Montauk, NY
$499,000236 Edgemere St Apt 411
Montauk, NY
There are currently 14 homes listed under $500,000 in Montauk, NY. This price range is popular with first-time buyers and investors looking for value in the Montauk market. HomeSwipr makes it easy to browse every listing — swipe right on the homes you love and our AI learns your taste to surface better matches over time.