Homes for Sale in Garden City, NY
61 listings available right now — swipe to find your perfect match.
Updated daily ·
61
Active Listings
$1,653,980
Avg. Price
$390,000
Starting From
$6,399,999
Up To
How much do homes cost in Garden City?
The median home price in Garden City is $1,350,000, with listings ranging from $390,000 to $6,399,999. Buyers can expect to pay around $665/sqft on average. Homes typically spend 122 days on market.
Price Distribution
Recent Price Drops in Garden City
1 Garden City home dropped price in the last 30 days.
Featured Listings in Garden City
Swipe all 61 →
$1,199,000175 Meadow St
Garden City, NY
$2,668,000132 Arthur St
Garden City, NY
$1,999,000142 Cambridge Ave
Garden City, NY
$619,00024 Hamilton Pl Apt F1
Garden City, NY
$1,849,99984 Nassau Blvd
Garden City, NY
$390,000127 Fifteenth St Unit E2
Garden City, NY
$1,485,0008 Andover Ct
Garden City, NY
$999,0008 3rd Pl
Garden City, NY
$2,695,000135 Adams St
Garden City, NY
$425,000113 15th St Unit 1C
Garden City, NY
$1,995,000168 Brixton Rd
Garden City, NY
$1,359,000210 Clinton Rd
Garden City, NY
$2,699,0007 Yale St
Garden City, NY
$719,00012 Hamilton Pl Apt B5
Garden City, NY
$1,649,00087 Wyatt Rd
Garden City, NY
$1,379,00055 Vassar St
Garden City, NY
$1,499,00087 Kingsbury Rd
Garden City, NY
$1,250,00040 Vassar St
Garden City, NY
$710,0002904451 33 Boylston St
Garden City, NY
$1,420,000105 Jefferson St
Garden City, NY
$1,219,0004 Main Ave
Garden City, NY
$2,199,00070 Magnolia Ave
Garden City, NY
$849,000112 New Hyde Park Rd
Garden City, NY
Best Value Picks in Garden City
Garden City homes priced below $665 per square foot — the city average. Sorted by lowest $/sqft.
$710,00086% below avg2904451 33 Boylston St
Garden City, NY
$95/sqft
$619,00038% below avg24 Hamilton Pl Apt F1
Garden City, NY
$413/sqft
$849,00035% below avg112 New Hyde Park Rd
Garden City, NY
$434/sqft
$390,00027% below avg127 Fifteenth St Unit E2
Garden City, NY
$488/sqft
$1,849,99924% below avg84 Nassau Blvd
Garden City, NY
$507/sqft
Browse all 61 Garden City homes on the map
Open map →Top-Rated Schools in Garden City
Schools serving multiple Garden City listings, rated 7+ on a 10-point scale.
Garden City High School
Stratford Avenue School
Garden City Middle School
Stewart School
About Garden City
Garden City is a village in Nassau County, on Long Island, in New York, United States. The population was 23,272 at the time of the 2020 census. (Wikipedia)
Climate: Average year-round temperature is 54°F with 212 dry days per year and 49.9 inches of annual rainfall.
What types of homes are for sale in Garden City?
Garden City listings average 3.7 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and 2,588 square feet. The average year built is 1949. Single Family homes are the most common property type, making up 93% of available inventory.
Find Your Dream Home in Garden City
HomeSwipr uses AI to learn what you love. Swipe right on homes you like and we'll surface better matches every time.
Start Swiping in Garden CityAbout Living in Garden City, New York
The Garden City market currently shows 61 active listings between $390,000 to $6,399,999, with a median asking price of $1,350,000, averaging $665 per square foot. Single Family homes lead inventory at 93% of listings. Condo (7%) round out the mix.
A typical Garden City listing offers 3.7 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, 2,588 square feet. Average year built: 1949. Homes typically go under contract after 122 days on market.
HomeSwipr makes it quick to explore every listing in Garden City — swipe right on the ones that catch your eye and left on the rest. The app learns what you actually want with every swipe, so matches get sharper the more you use it.
Frequently asked questions about homes for sale in Garden City
How many homes are for sale in Garden City, NY?
There are 61 homes for sale in Garden City, NY right now, with prices ranging from $390,000 to $6,399,999. Inventory is refreshed daily from live listing feeds.
What is the median home price in Garden City?
The median home price in Garden City is $1,350,000, with an average of $1,653,980. Prices span $390,000 to $6,399,999 across 61 current listings.
What is the average price per square foot in Garden City?
The average price per square foot in Garden City is $665 based on current listings. Per-sqft varies meaningfully by neighborhood and property type within the city.
What types of homes are for sale in Garden City?
Single Family homes dominate Garden City inventory at 93% of listings. Condo (7%) round out the mix.
What does a typical Garden City home look like?
A typical Garden City listing offers 3.7 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and 2,588 square feet, with an average year built of 1949.
How long do Garden City homes stay on the market?
Garden City homes have been on the market an average of 122 days. Newer listings (under 7 days) typically indicate fresh inventory worth early attention.
Narrow Your Garden City Search
Compare Garden City to Other Markets
Garden City vs Austin — cost of living
Side-by-side median prices, price/sqft, and property mix.
Garden City vs Denver — cost of living
Side-by-side median prices, price/sqft, and property mix.
Garden City vs Nashville — cost of living
Side-by-side median prices, price/sqft, and property mix.
Garden City vs Miami — cost of living
Side-by-side median prices, price/sqft, and property mix.